The Sommelier's Rules for Pairing with Fire
Smoke changes everything about wine pairing — five rules Marcus applies at every table, every night.
Smoke is a seasoning — it needs fruit and acid to balance, not more weight.
Charred fat asks for tannin — but the right age of tannin.
The best pairing for fire is rarely the obvious big red.
Smoke is a seasoning, not a flavour
Most pairing advice treats a grilled steak like a roasted one. It isn't. Wood smoke wraps the protein in a volatile layer of compounds that reads as bitter to a heavy wine and as nothing to a timid one. The pairing has to meet the smoke first, the meat second.
The mistake I see nightly: reaching for the biggest Barossa block available. Big wine plus big smoke equals a fight. The right answer is usually a wine with ripe fruit, confident acid and resolved tannin — structure that frames the smoke rather than competing with it.
Match the wine to the fire first and the meat second — the smoke is the loudest thing on the plate.
Marcus Devereux, Head Sommelier
The five rules I pour by
One: acid before weight — a leaner wine with better acid beats a fat wine every time against char. Two: age resolves tannin — young tannic reds scrape against smoke; five-plus years lets them frame it. Three: don't fear white — an aged Hunter semillon beside coal-grilled fish embarrasses most reds.
Four: sherry is the cheat code — amontillado with smoked anything is the pairing professionals reach for and never mention. Five: match the course, not the cuisine — the raw bar wants saline whites, the grill wants structured reds, the cheese wants whatever's left and interesting.
Four takeaways
The short version, for the notes app.
Acid first — it cuts smoke the way it cuts fat.
Age softens — resolved tannin frames smoke; young tannin fights it.
Whites can win — aged semillon and smoked fish is a chef-secret pairing.
Sherry always works — amontillado beside anything smoked, no debate.
Let us pour the argument
The tastings in the vault walk through these rules with actual glasses — the Blind Flight session teaches you to find them yourself.
Or simply order the pairing with the degustation — the sommelier applies all five rules to seven courses so you don't have to.
Marcus Devereux
Head Sommelier — built the 400-label cellar from a single shelf of Barossa shiraz in 2011.
More from the journal
Quick answers
Drink like the sommelier
Book a tasting and let eight glasses teach what articles only describe.